April 10, 2008

twitter and XMPP

Filed under:, , , — cwage @ 10:41 am

A chain of thought I had this morning:

  • Twitter is fun and (tentatively) tremendously useful, albeit difficult to explain
  • Twitter is a centralized proprietary service, and thus prone to issues of scaling (outages), and privacy.
  • Twitter is not magic technology --XMPP and SMS gateways could basically do everything it does now.
  • That's nice and all, but Twitter has the user-base.
  • XMPP has a track record of being Really Cool Technology that languishes in obscurity due to its lack of user-friendly implementations and wide user-base adoption.
  • Google saved XMPP from a similar languishing death in the world of Instant Messaging by adopting this open standard as the basis for Google Talk.
  • Conclusion: Google needs to re-factor Google Talk to be/add a twitter-alike service.


  • http://blog.calevans.com Cal Evans

    "That’s nice and all, but Twitter has the user-base."
    ...and therin lies the rub. There are other system out there like twitter and more feature-rich, but twitter wins because twitter has the users.


  • http://chris.quietlife.net Chris

    If only there were some company with pockets deep enough to build something better and buy Twitter. :)